Dutch Man Loses Bid To Change His Age, Plans To Appeal
A 69-year-old Dutchman who lost a court case on his request to reduce his official age by 20 years says he plans to appeal.
Emile Ratelband says he feels younger than his real age and, as NPR previously reported, he maintains his life, and performance on dating apps, would improve if his legal age were 49. He said he would be willing to delay receiving a pension.
A district court in the eastern Dutch city of Arnhem was not convinced.
"[U]nlike the situation with respect to a change in registered name or gender, there are a variety of rights and duties related to age, such as the right to vote and the duty to attend school," the court wrote in a statement. "If Mr Ratelband's request was allowed, those age requirements would become meaningless."
There was no evidence that Ratelband had experienced age discrimination, the court said. And it rejected his argument on the basis of free will, writing that "free will does not extend so far as to make every desired outcome legally possible."
"Mr Ratelband is at liberty to feel 20 years younger than his real age and to act accordingly," the court continued. "But amending his date of birth would cause 20 years of records to vanish from the register of births, deaths, marriages and registered partnerships. This would have a variety of undesirable legal and societal implications."
Ratelband was not discouraged by the decision. "The reaction of the judges is fantastic, is great," he said.
"You know why? Because we have a strategy," he added, referring to his plan to address on appeal the specific reasons the judge gave in rejecting the age change.
Ratelband says he expects his appeal to be heard in the coming months.
Ratelband denied bringing his case in order to criticize or discredit transgender people, although he has repeatedly compared his quixotic crusade to their battle to have their gender identity recognized.
In the Netherlands, Ratelband's actions, and the international exposure he's garnered, have been met with mockery and bemusement.
"The Netherlands laughs at the crazy Emile, who meanwhile gives interviews around the world," wrote the Dutch newspaper Algemeen Dagblad.
It called Ratelband's claim that he's younger than his true age "absurd."
Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.